The Delight of Unfinished Mathematics
We have been told that a perfect mathematics lesson is a seamless, distraction-free highway where every student achieves success and closure by the bell. But what if the most delightful mathematical experiences are those that refuse to end? What if a lingering question, an unresolved conjecture, or an unexpected mathematical surprise is not evidence of incomplete teaching, but an invitation to keep thinking?
As educators, we often design lessons like Disney movies: a clear beginning, rising action, heroic breakthrough, and a tidy ending where everyone rides off into the sunset of mastery. Drawing on work with Constantinos Xenofontos on non-linearity in mathematics education, alongside the Zeigarnik and Ovsiankina effects, I want to explore the possibilities of productively sabotaging this obsession with pedagogical neatness. Perhaps the goal is not always to leave students satisfied, but to leave them sufficiently intrigued, unsettled, or delighted that they cannot resist but to dwell with or return to the mathematics.
What might such moments reveal about mathematical promise that conventional measures of achievement overlook? How might curiosity, persistence, play, and the desire to return to unfinished ideas become ways of recognizing and nurturing mathematical potential? Drawing on The Creative Mathematics Teacher’s Book of Lists, I will invite participants into a little unfinished mathematics and offer a playful list of instructional gimmicks to try. Delight becomes the joy of thinking and working mathematically rather than the reward for arriving at an answer and stopping.
Peter Appelbaum is Professor of Education and Director of Education Studies at Arcadia University in Philadelphia, USA. A curriculum theorist and mathematics educator, he blends arts and critical reflection on school structures, inviting others to unlearn rigid linearity and experience mathematics as playful, embodied cultural expressions. He is a past Vice President of the International Commission for the Study and Improvement of Mathematics Education/Teaching (CIEAEM), has chaired international program work for CIEAEM, and is associated with the Youth Mathematician Laureate Project. He is interested in productive ambiguities and paradoxes, community-based non-school environments, and the nurturing of mathematical promise as civic responsibility. Dr. Appelbaum is the author, among others, of Embracing mathematics: On becoming a teacher and changing with mathematics, The creative mathematics teacher's book of lists, and Post-Anthropocene civic and global education studies: Beyond posthuman perspectives.

